A hard money construction completion loan seems pretty easy and straightforward at 65-75% of as-is value of a...
Do You Offer a Hard Money Second Mortgage to Cover Down Payment and Closing Costs?
This question has come in through the website dozens of the times over the years from prospective house flippers who are short on funds to close their transaction. What they’re asking for is something called “Gap Funding,” which is a hard money second mortgage that “fills the gap” when not having funds for down payment and closing costs.
FCTD doesn’t originate stand-alone second position gap funding loans behind a high-leverage fix and flip loan because the risks are too high, far outweighing the reward, which I’ll go into below.
This blog post will break down a recent request from a house flipper purchasing a fixer upper for $480,000 and requesting a second trust deed to cover down payment and closing costs. I’ll cover all the aspects that you need to know before continuing down this path, including:
- Does the first mortgage lender even allow a junior lien?
- If possible, what do the second mortgage terms look like?
- What are the potential risks and costs to the second lienholder?
Below is a summary of the loan request that came in requesting the hard money second mortgage:
“Another lender approved me for a first mortgage of $420,000 without any rehab funds on a $480,000 purchase. The rehab budget is $75,000 and will take about 3 months. I’ll pay all rehab fees out of pocket. The After Repair Value is $650,000. I need a second mortgage for the down payment and closing costs. Close of escrow is in 5 days. Please call me immediately.”
There are a few things that immediately caught my attention:
- 50% Loan-To-Value (LTV) on the first mortgage:
The LTV loan commitment makes me think financing is probably coming from an institutional fix and flip lender that sells these loans off to Wall Street or other fixed income investors.
I’m certain that they do not allow a junior lien (more below).
- No money to bring in for down payment and closing costs:
Is that because the borrower is inexperienced? I doubt it because the lender offered 87.50% LTV.
Do they have other projects that are delayed?
If so, are they overleveraged across their projects?
Are they in default or at risk of default?
Overleveraged and/or defaulted borrowers sometimes try avoiding disclosure of other projects in progress or in default. A quick background check can find that information because hard money loans aren’t reported on personal credit reports.
- Close of escrow in 5 days:
Being under the gun to act fast on a scenario that, if we find a way to move forward, will require significant due diligence since this borrower is brand new to FCTD.
I would order an appraisal, request tax returns, bank statements, schedule of real estate with all mortgages, credit report, and will run a background check to look for foreclosures, judgments, liens, financial convictions, tax liens, etc.
Plus, we’d need to work with the first lienholder on an Intercreditor Agreement so that the second lienholder would be notified if the borrower defaulted on the first (Very Important).
Let’s discuss this in more detail.
Does the first mortgage lender even allow a junior lien?
The first thing to do is ask the first mortgage lender for a proposed version of the Note to see if there is any “due on sale” language prohibiting a junior lien to be recorded on title. As I mentioned in #1 above, I suspect the $420,000 loan commitment to the borrower came from an institutional fix and flip lender that originates and sells loans immediately to a secondary market investor. FCTD works with several institutional lenders and the loan documents are streamlined with “due on sale” language that does not allow a junior lien on the property.
Here’s an example of due on sale language regarding junior liens from the Note an institutional lender:
There is no way that the institutional lender would allow a hard money second mortgage to close concurrently. They wouldn’t be able to sell the loan to the secondary market investor and would instead either need to carry it on their warehouse line or sell the loan at a discount.
If possible, what do the second mortgage terms look like?
Let’s say the first mortgage did allow junior liens, and if you could find a trust deed investor willing to do a very high-leverage second mortgage behind an already high-leverage first mortgage.
What would the terms of a second mortgage look like?
In the example above, I used a cost of 5 Points at 15.00% but I think for this level of risk, it could be more.
You might be wondering why I made the second mortgage balance $91,000 rather than $60,000. It’s because the first mortgage lender will “net fund” the loan, excluding their 3% loan fee. Then, you have the other closing costs, title and escrow, 12 months of insurance premium, and prepaid interest on the mortgage. That comes out to $24,350, which would have to be absorbed by the second mortgage holder on top of the $60,000 down payment. The second mortgage will also have loan fees and closing costs from title and escrow, which gets us to a $91,000 loan amount.
Between both loans and standard closing costs, the borrower is looking at $31,200 closing costs with very expensive financing.
What are the potential risks and costs to the second lienholder?
This is where you need to put your lender hat on and think like a lender. As a borrower in this scenario, you go in optimistically thinking that you’ll rehab this property within 2-3 months and get a full price offer within a week of going on the market, netting $50,000 profit in a few months. In this scenario, the lender will make their 5 points ($4,550) plus 4 months of interest ($4,550).
As a lender, or a mortgage broker who has been around 20+ years, we think the opposite and want to calculate what it would cost in the event of a default, not just on the second mortgage, but on the first mortgage. Usually, if one loan is in default, the other loan is also in default.
Private money fix and flip loans usually have late charges of 10% and a default interest rate, from 15.00% to 24.00%, which kicks in after the 10-day grace period for the monthly payment.
I mentioned in #3 above that if I could find a second mortgage for this scenario, I’d need to work out an Intercreditor Agreement between the first and second lienholders. This is where it comes into play.
If our borrower defaults on the first mortgage of $420,000 with a $3,500/mo payment, a late fee of $350 will be charged and the default interest rate of 24.00% will kick in, resulting in a $8,400/mo payment. (I used a default interest rate of 24.00% to make it scarier).
The first lienholder will notify the second lienholder of the default. Most likely, the second mortgage will also be in default and the second lienholder will file a foreclosure action, which can take 3-6 months, depending on the property state. The first lienholder will most likely file a foreclosure action as well, so there could be two concurrent foreclosures progressing at the same time.
While the second lien is working toward a foreclosure sale to close out the $91,000 junior position, the first mortgage balance, if still in default, is growing by nearly $10,000 per month with the late charges, the $8,400/mo default payment, and foreclosure fees accruing.
Let’s say the second lien is foreclosed in six months, which means that the delinquent first mortgage balance grew from the original $420,000 to $480,000. The second lienholder has options and can either pay off the entire first mortgage for $480,000, service the debt at $8,400/mo (remember – the first mortgage is still in default), or cure the default for approximately $60,000 to bring the interest rate back down to 10.00% with a $3,500/mo payment to be paid until the property sells.
Below, I used the option where they cured the first mortgage default for $60,000:
Now that the second lienholder has title with the first mortgage delinquency cured, it’s time to finish the rehab project, which came with an initial $75,000 budget. Hopefully, the home is in good condition and that contractors and supplies are readily available to complete the project and sell the house for the $650,000 target price.
To salvage that $91,000 second mortgage, the second lienholder will have to spend an additional $154,000, bringing their total outlay up to $245,000 just to get the house ready to sell.
Hopefully, the second lienholder turned house flipper didn’t run into any unforeseen delays in completing project. If they can sell for $650,000, they’d recoup some of the $154,000 but would still wind up with a $54,000 loss prior to pursuing a deficiency judgment against the borrower, who would have signed a Personal Guaranty in the loan documents for both loans, even if the loan was made to an LLC.
All of this time, energy, and money spent to salvage a $91,000 initial investment netting in a $54,000 loss. It’s hard for an experienced trust deed investor to want to take the plunge with an investor who is new to them.
As you can see, seeking out gap funding, or a hard money second mortgage to cover down payment and closing costs, is incredibly risky (expensive) for a trust deed investor if things go sideways. If you already have financing in place with a high-leverage first mortgage lender, likely an institutional fix and flip lender, you’ll need to confirm that their loan allows for junior liens.
Most every trust deed investor FCTD works with will not do these loans in this structure. I’ve written a blog post, Alternatives to Gap Funding Second Mortgages, that has some other ways you could go about getting the financing secured.
The short answer is: “Yes.” Over the past year, we at First Capital Trust Deeds have been originating more and...